Return to Table of Contents

Modern Spiritual Paths

Religion serves as the glue that holds community together.  It provides our moral and ethical values, and it asks us to seek and manifest higher virtue.  Religion gives the community various traditions and symbols that provide focus, direction, and cohesion.  It also suggests possible answers to the unanswerable questions of life, such as ‘Why am I here’ and ‘What is life’s purpose’?

The shadow side of religion can be harmful in that it may focus on power, hierarchical concealment, and war in the name of God.  However, if we are aware of the pitfalls, we are better prepared to avoid the trap. 

 

Why Religion?

A quote from Joseph Campbell opens our dialog on religions: “An honest comparison immediately reveals that all [religions] have been built from one fund of mythological motifs – variously selected, organized, interpreted, and ritualized, according to local need, but revered by every people on earth” (1987, p. 4).  In this quote, Campbell is telling us that all religions originate from the same archetypal story, and that the various religions are an outgrowth of different tribal or cultural traditions.  Indeed, society needs religion as a container for its mythological history.

The religious archetype stems from humanity’s roots, and humankind needs myth to make sense of life circumstances.  “Man, apparently, cannot maintain himself in the universe without belief in some arrangement of the general inheritance of myth.  In fact, the fullness of his life would even seem to stand in a direct relation to the depth and range not of his rational thought but of his local mythology” (Campbell, 1987, p. 4).  Myths are stories that stimulate the imagination and the heart and exist as a part of our archetypal heritage.  Mythological themes of death and resurrection, the virgin birth, and creation appear in all the various religions and cannot be claimed as exclusive to any major religious group (Eliade, 1967). 

Our mythological dramas are born out of the same consciousness as the four year old’s magical playtime.  When the four year old pretends to be the ‘witch’, she truly ‘becomes’ the witch in her own imagination.  Today’s religious liturgy is an outgrowth of this magical consciousness that created the ancient gods.  Many of today’s religious rituals are based on pagan rites that were assimilated in an attempt to appeal to the members of the community.  Religion is compelling because it is magical, and it excites the primitive and emotionally charged part of the brain that seeks answers to life’s mysteries. 

Today’s world is rooted in the rational, however science cannot provide us with answers or reasons for our existence, nor can it give us a sense of the meaning or purpose in our lives.  Religion’s task is to provide us with these answers, because meaning and purpose presuppose and demand an understanding of the unknown esoteric realms that science cannot fathom.  Birth, death, and the hereafter is the domain of mystery - what meaning does existence itself possess if some part of us does not survive the death of the body?  Our myths, dreams, fantasies, and imaginings flow from mystical realms of consciousness, and they provide our answers to these questions.  Religion’s purpose is to give meaning and structure to these mystical experiences.

 

Religious Symbolism

As noted before, Jung coined the term archetype to represent a collective image that occurs across cultures.  The same motifs play out in all tribes, and these archetypes preserve the collective energy or roles necessary for survival.  A tribe cannot exist without a healing force, ruling force, and Warrior force.  The Divine or God force is also necessary, because it explains existence and gives community a model for morality, ethics, and the fair and just treatment of others.  It is a civilizing energy and it supplies a container for the expansion and evolution of consciousness.

Religion elicits an emotional response, much like art and poetry.  Ancient art was probably an attempt to express the mythical nature of the culture.  Artistic renderings on cave walls may indeed represent prayers offered to the gods as an attempt to control the day-to-day functioning of the good hunt, the weather, the birth and death of individuals, and the rise and rule of nobles.  Campbell notes that “mythology is a rendition of forms through which the formless Form of forms can be known” (1987, p 55).  He is saying that mythology gives us an outer or concrete picture that represents the inner or ‘formless form’ so that we can make the leap in consciousness from the outer or perceptual realm to the inner or mystical realm.  Indeed, this is its purpose.  Religion is a product of the consciousness that experiences the numinous.

Thus, the outer symbol is a description or representation of the internal and eternally mystical in the same way that art, music, poetry, and writing are outer symbols or descriptions of an internal experience.  We see a rose, and we call it a rose, but the name is not the experience of the rose.  Harry Palmer (1997) explains that this is the difference between a word lesson and a world lesson, meaning that the name or label is not the experience of the thing itself.  We face the same difficulty when we try to describe or name the Ultimate Reality or God, because the name of God is not the experience of God. 

Religion arises from our most basic tribal roots.  The first gods were nature gods, representative of the natural forces of the world.  Myths arose around birth, death, and regeneration as an attempt to explain and understand.  Thus, gods were born out of human self awareness.  When people first recognized their mortality, they needed to make sense of life, and over the centuries, tribes formed vast traditions and teachings in response to basic life questions.  Campbell (1987) tells us that mythological themes parallel civilization advances, and the first figurines of goddesses appear around 4500 to 3500 B.C.  It is not a far stretch to imagine that goddesses were connected with fertility and represented a good harvest and lavish food supply.  By revering the goddess, the tribe ensured the harvest, and over time, elaborate rituals and traditions were created to appease the goddess. 

Campbell (1987) postulates two ways of understanding our symbols, rituals, and traditions – the elementary and ethnic.  First, a ritual has an ‘elementary’ aspect, an esoteric or universal theme that is common to all cultures and traditions.  The elementary theme is interpreted and understood through the ‘ethnic’ traditions which are cultural, historical or sociological in nature and specific to the place and time.  The universal or elementary aspect transforms and disengages the individual from the local and leads him to the ineffable or numinous experience.  The ethnic or historical ties the individual to his culture and society, his family and history.  Confusion arises when one is unable to understand both aspects.  If one uses a symbol purely as a historical tie to ethnic rituals and rites, then the symbol loses its mystical and transcending nature.  It also keeps the individual locked in his own tribal translation of the universal principle.  This results in religious separation and misunderstanding, because other ethnic forms from other tribes will not be accepted or appreciated as similar yet unique expressions of the esoteric principle. 

Thus the same universal deity can be worshipped by different individuals from different vantage points and be experienced in vastly different ways.  Religious adherents from different tribes may have a completely different experience of the same Deity based on the level of consciousness or cultural tradition from which they experience that Deity.  By contrast, individuals from vastly different ethnic backgrounds can experience different tribal Deities in the same ecstatic experience if they see the underlying universal principle.  They understand that different Deities are expressions of the same esoteric principle, even though they call them by different names.

It is the ethnic difference that causes wars.  Religion emphasizes the ethnic understanding of the cultural Deity and loses the Mystical or spiritual experience that embraces the esoteric or numinous understanding of the formless.  The ethnic ties us to the world, and the esoteric elevates us in consciousness to the experience of the Divine.  The ethnic yokes us to cultural experiences of pleasure, power, and the laws of virtue, and the esoteric releases us into enlightenment and transcendence.  The true role and purpose of the ethnic is to lead us to the esoteric, but it requires a deeper understanding and development in consciousness for this movement to occur. 

Religious followers mistake the literal form for the symbolic form at certain levels of consciousness.  The individual in Fowler’s (1987) Stage 3 consciousness does not understand that the symbol is not the full reality, and he gives symbolic form a literal meaning.  The stage 5 individual understands that the literal and the symbolic exist in the same form.  An individual in Stage 2 or 3 faith is willing to fight wars over this literal understanding which is why an expansion of consciousness and an understanding of faith development are necessary for world survival. 

 Next